Blagoevgrad, Bulgaria

The Marxist ideology and socialism were in theory supposed to eradicate social classes and put everyone on equal footing. That was certainly not the outcome and housing, more specifically the distribution of dwellings, can account for that. Described by academic works (again, Brigitte Le Normand’s book Designing Tito’s Capital: Urban Planning, Modernism, and Socialism in Belgrade is a Bible), bribery (ties with the Party could help), bypassing (long, reportedly up to years!) waiting list and tinkering of all sorts (faking divorce, for example) allowed for some lucky citizens to get better apartments, or to get them faster. Army officials and Party members had better housing conditions. On the opposite, people with low-salary, or unable to work, were regrouped in poorly built apartments financed by public funds. An empathetic gesture in appearance, a blessing in disguise given the conditions of the blocks. There could be three generations living in one single flat not necessarily salubrious.

Stara Zagora, Bulgaria

The cramped living conditions are still experienced today. This article explores the life in a flat of a Ukrainian family that, as many others, inherited this situation from the socialist period.

After the fall of socialism, apartments were privatized (most of them were state-owned before). This only made the gap between the social classes that emerged bigger, as people have different financial means. In Romania’s Bucharest, the distinction in classes matches neighborhoods (see the research Urban Geographies of Hesitant Transition: Tracing Socioeconomic Segregation in Post‐Ceauşescu Bucharest).

Beyond the segregation caused by corruption of the system and income, is a segregation of minority groups. Balkan countries are known for their melting-pot of ethnicities that was tolerated during the Ottoman rule, less so when the new states were defining their concept of nationality. To draw on Ceausescu’s example, ethnic minorities were specifically targeted in the destroying of villages. Hungarians inhabiting Transylvania for generations were pressured to leave their villages, which resulted in growing tensions between Hungary and Romania. Turns out that national identity was deemed more important than equality.

A lingering problem that can be seen today in Balkan cities are the marginalized minorities living in precarious conditions on the outskirts of the urban territory. The first that comes to mind is the Roma population. Numerous especially in Romania and Bulgaria, Roma’s neighborhoods are easily identified, not by the people, but mostly by the decaying state of the apartment blocks.

Razgrad, one of Bulgaria’s city where the population is mostly Muslim

A focus on Bucharest’s infamous neighborhood Ferentari shows how these sectors are the forgotten margins of the Balkan cities. The persecutions of the Roma minority, in particular, that peeked during the Second World War, is lingering today in the form of abuses in housing. Ferentari is a neighborhood inhabited mostly by low-income Romas. The apartment blocks are insalubrious, cramped, and the abuse problems of the residents and other signs of poverty and lack of care from Bucharest are showing in the streets. Leases and rents are such that people are accumulating debts and are stuck there, unable to make their financial status better. Please see this article and this article to learn more and visualize the situation.

Programs exists and measures are taken, like the Decade of Roma Inclusion, to improve the quality of life and bring back the inhabitants of this post-socialist ghetto into Bucharest. But the road is long, and it is valuable to realize how socialist housing conditions are the roots of some of the segregation problems seen today in Balkan cities.

8 commentaires »

  1. All is said, well illustrated (very nice pics !), nothing to add here!
    It’s an A+ work up to here, honest !
    Not that I want to influence anybody…😏

    David
    On my way to become a brutalist lover, as expected !

    J’aime

  2. Je suis d’accord pour la note À+attribuée par David même s’il ne veut influencer personne. Mais si tu crois avoir trouvé un adepte de cette architecture, je sais qu’il serait malheureux dans ce décor trop sévère. La verdure, l’espace et les oiseaux lui manqueraient.

    Aimé par 1 personne

    • Haha c’est gentil! Oui le manque d’espace vert est un problème, maximiser l’espace pour les blocs n’a pas permis d’en avoir… ça cause d’autres problèmes aujourd’hui, comme le manque de stationnement…

      J’aime

    • En Roumanie, les gens disent que quand ce sera la fin du monde, ils vont le savoir seulement 20 ans plus tard… On dirait que l’échelle du temps n’est pas la même, et ces blocs ramènent dans le passé!
      J’ai été surprise aussi en visitant l’Allemagne, on voit que là-bas c’était important pour eux de rénover les blocs!

      Aimé par 1 personne

Votre commentaire

Entrez vos coordonnées ci-dessous ou cliquez sur une icône pour vous connecter:

Logo WordPress.com

Vous commentez à l’aide de votre compte WordPress.com. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Image Twitter

Vous commentez à l’aide de votre compte Twitter. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Photo Facebook

Vous commentez à l’aide de votre compte Facebook. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Connexion à %s